Halloween is creeping up on us, folks! And as the spooky season descends, so does the annual hunt for the best Halloween candies. We're talking about the sweet treats that make your taste buds do a happy dance and have trick-or-treaters screaming (with delight, of course). This year, instead of settling for the same old candy corn, why not explore some new, mouthwatering options?
Here at Peter Piper's Picks, we've been as busy as witches in a broom factory, scouring the web and diving deep into the cauldron of customer reviews, ratings, and popularity metrics. We've also tapped into our inner sweet tooth and lifelong love of Hershey, all in the name of helping you find the confectionery delights that will make this Halloween unforgettable.
Peter Piper's Picks participates in Amazon Associates and other affiliate programs. We may earn commissions from purchases made by following links from our website. There is never any additional cost to you.
How Peter Piper Picks The Best Halloween Candies
Halloween's a blast! But, oh boy, picking the perfect candy can make your head spin like a top. So many sweets to choose from: lollipops, sour candies, chocolates, gummies... it's a candy jungle out there! But don't sweat it!
Your ghoulish friends at Peter Piper's Picks have done the candy homework for you. We've checked out candy ratings and reviews while focusing on taste, quality, price, and what's popular. Our mission? To help you find the Halloween treats that'll make you the talk of Trick-or-Treat town. So, chill out, chomp on your favorite tootsie pop or sour gummy worm, and let's explore our top Halloween candy picks together!
The Sweet Sting: Unraveling the World of Sour Candies
Sour candies, including favorites like sour gummy worms, are like a wild rollercoaster ride for your mouth. Imagine the sharp tang of sour lemon or sour orange at first, then the sweet aftertaste. Some of the most popular sour candies include Sour Punch Twists and Haribo Sour Goldbears, which are often rated as top picks on Amazon.
For a different twist, tart candy offers a slightly less intense but equally exciting flavor journey. For the brave candy explorers, ultra-sour treats like Barnett's Mega Sour Fizz Bombs and Toxic Waste, not to mention the tongue-twisting goodness of sour gummy worms, push your palate to the limit. But remember, the sour candy adventure isn't just about the face-puckering start; it's also about the sweet finish line! Here are two of our top picks:
Great for Halloween Parties, and Move Nights
Sour Patch Kids and Swedish Fish Variety Pack
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Get ready for a flavor fiesta with the Sour Patch Kids and Swedish Fish Variety Pack! This confectionary combo is a Halloween hero, packed with sour, sweet, and fruity fun to please trick-or-treaters and party hoppers. Inside, you'll find six packs each of three tongue-tingling flavors: Sour Patch Kids, refreshing Watermelon candies, and classic chewy Swedish Fish.
These aren't just candies for a special night; they're flavor-filled adventures! Each pack is individually sized and sealed for freshness, making them perfect for lunch boxes, road trips, Halloween bags, or even desk drawer snacks. So, if you're hunting for a Halloween hit, this variety pack is a top-notch pick. With an extra punch of sourness, it's a whirlwind of flavors for everyone!
Perfect Mix of Sweet and Sour
Juicy Drop Dip 'N Stix Halloween Candy Variety Pack
Why Peter Piper Picked It
The Juicy Drop Dip 'N Stix variety pack contains 8 individual confection cups in four delicious flavors: Knock-Out Punch, Watermelon Blast, Blue Rebel, and Wild Cherry Berry. Each cup comes with sweet gummy stix and a sour gel, allowing kids to control their flavor experience. They can dip as much or as little as they want: creating the perfect mix of sweet and sour in every bite.
If you're looking for a Halloween confection that offers a unique and engaging taste experience, the Juicy Drop Dip 'N Stix variety pack is a great choice. With its mix of sweet and sour flavors and fun dip-and-eat format, it's sure to be a hit with kids and adults alike.
Lollipops: A Whirl of Flavors on a Stick
Lollipops are a sugary swirl of fun on a stick, loved by kids and adults alike! These timeless treats offer a simple yet exciting journey of flavors that you can enjoy at your own pace. They might lack the biting thrill of sour candies, but they make up for it with their steady, delightful sweetness. Any adult who grew up on dum dums or charms will tell you lollipops are a staple of candy cuisine.
With a rainbow of flavors from classic cherry and apple to adventurous blue raspberry, there's a sucker for every taste bud. To daddies, mummies, and the walking dead, lollipops add a sweet dimension to any Halloween festivity. And here's our top pick:
Best for Caramel Lovers
Tootsie Pops Limited Edition Caramel Flavored Lollipops
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Ready for a Halloween treat that's a twist on a classic? Say hello to Tootsie Pops Limited Edition Caramel Flavored Lollipops! These pops pack a punch of rich caramel flavor, encasing a chocolatey Tootsie Roll center for an indulgent gourmet experience. This one-flavor bag contains approximately 21 pops per pack: they're perfect for sharing at Halloween parties or satisfying your sugary cravings.
And guess what? They're more than just yummy—they're also kosher, peanut-free, and gluten-free! So, they're a safe bet for those with special dietary needs. The big 12.6-ounce bag is great for filling up candy bowls at the office or reception desk, and each pop is wrapped individually for freshness and easy distribution. Attention caramel lovers, your perfect Halloween candy is here—Tootsie Pops Caramel Flavored Lollipops are a hit with kids and adults alike!
Chocolate Candy: The Classic Crowd Pleaser
Chocolate is the superstar of Halloween candy! It's a classic crowd-pleaser that makes everyone grin from ear to ear. Whether you're a fan of smooth milk chocolate or fancy the richness of dark chocolate, there's a chocolate confection out there just for you.
And the fun doesn't stop at chocolate bars—you can also find treats like chocolate-covered nuts and fruits. So, no matter what your Halloween confection checklist looks like, chocolate has got you covered! And here's our top 3 picks perfect for this Halloween season:
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Calling all peanut butter lovers! Reese's White Ghosts are Halloween treats you can't resist. These ghost-shaped goodies put a fun twist on classic Reese's cups, with a white creme shell hiding a creamy peanut butter heart. Perfect for any Halloween event, from costume parties to pumpkin carving, these individually wrapped candies come in a festive Halloween bag that adds a spooky touch to your celebrations.
But these ghosts offer more than just a tasty treat! Pair them with milk, hot cocoa, or coffee for a delicious combo you can definitely finish in one sitting! You can also get creative and use them in homemade Halloween treats—wrap them in cookie dough for a melty surprise, or add icing for extra fun. In short, Reese's White Ghosts are a fun, flavorful, and festive must-have for your Halloween festivities!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Get ready for a Halloween snack with a twist! OREO BOO Orange Crème Chocolate Sandwich Cookies are the perfect treat for all you OREO fans out there. Imagine your favorite chocolate wafers sandwiching an orange-colored crème filling - that's a Halloween party in your mouth!
Each pack has five spooky cookie designs to add a bit of fun to your snack time. They're great for dunking, adding to party mixes, or handing out in trick-or-treat bags. Plus, they come in a handy resealable 1.25 lb. pack to keep them fresh, and at only 140 calories per serving, they're a guilt-free treat. If you're on the hunt for a fun, tasty, and festive Halloween snack, OREO BOO Orange Crème Chocolate Sandwich Cookies are the way to go!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Does Count Dracula have a favorite candy? You bet! Check out Hershey's Cookies 'n Creme Halloween Fangs! These aren't your typical Hershey's bars—they've got a monstrous twist that's perfect for cookie and cream lovers. Imagine crunchy chocolate cookie pieces mixed with smooth white creme. Yum, right?
But these confection bars aren't just delicious, they're a whole lot of fun too! With their fang-bearing design, they're sure to add a spooky touch to birthday parties, movie nights, Halloween party favors, and trick-or-treat bags. It's also Kosher-certified making it safe for people with certain dietary restrictions. So get ready to take your celebrations up a notch with Hershey's Cookies 'n Creme Halloween Fangs (and don't forget to be back inside your bed chambers by sunrise)!
Trending Candy: Staying Ahead of the Candy Curve
Keeping up with the latest confection trends can add an exciting twist to your Halloween candy selection. This year, why not surprise your trick-or-treaters with some trending candies? Some of the current favorites include Sour Skittles and Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers, which are taking the sour candy world by storm. And let's not forget about Fun Dip Sour and Koala Jumbo Sour Suckers, which are gaining popularity among sour candy enthusiasts. By incorporating these trending candies into your Halloween stash, you'll surely be the talk of the neighborhood. We have 5 top picks for this section:
Why Peter Piper Picked It
These aren't your everyday chews, they're a fun and fruity twist on the classic Tootsie Roll. Each piece bursts with a tangy fruit punch flavor that keeps going even after the candy is gone. And with 360 pieces per bag, you'll have plenty to share this Halloween. There are 10 delicious Frooties flavors to try, including grape, strawberry, green apple, blue raspberry, watermelon, strawberry lemonade, lemon-lime, cherry limeade, chocolate, and mango.
But the fun doesn't stop there—these candies are also perfect for pep rallies, birthday parties, weddings, or confection buffets. Plus, each piece is only 11 calories and is kosher, gluten-free, and peanut-free, so everyone can enjoy it! Why wait? Dive into the world of Frooties Tootsie Roll Fruit Flavored Chewy Candy and make this Halloween the tastiest one yet!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Get ready for a blast from the past with Airheads Chewy Fruit Taffy, the best Halloween confection that's more than just a treat—it's a fun, colorful, and tangy adventure! With six zingy fruit flavors—Cherry, White Mystery, Blue Raspberry, Watermelon, Orange, and Grape—every bite will have you guessing and wanting more. This variety pack comes with 60 individual bars, perfect for sharing with trick-or-treaters, family, and friends, or even for stashing in your pantry for those sudden sweet cravings.
They're peanut-free, tree nut-free, gluten-free, and kosher, making them a joy for everyone. Plus, these candies don't melt, meaning they can hang out in your pocket all day and still keep their shape and texture. And if you're craving something bite-sized, be sure to check out Airheads Bites. This year, greet your candy-courting guests with Airheads Chewy Fruit Taffy and make your Halloween a fruity, chewy, and delightful affair!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
This box is a candy lover's dream, bursting with four famous lollipop brands - Ring Pop, Push Pop, Baby Bottle Pop, and Juicy Drop. Ready to take your taste buds on an adventure? Dive into exciting flavors like Strawberry Lemonade, Blue Raspberry, and Cherry Watermelon. With 18 individual lollipops, it's perfect for Halloween parties, awesome party favors, or a sweet treat for yourself.
But wait, there's more! This confection box isn't just tasty, it's super versatile and shelf-stable too. It's great for birthdays, Halloween bashes, or just to have some fun goodies at home. Plus, it makes a sweet gift for your candy-craving pals. So, if you're after a Halloween option that's fun, flavorful, and sure to be a hit with kids and grown-ups alike, pick the Bazooka Candy Brands Halloween Candy Box!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Strawberry lovers, unite! This Halloween, let's twist it up with the Twizzlers Twists Strawberry Flavored Licorice. With a fun twisty design and a yum-tastic strawberry taste, they're a fresh spin on your standard licorice candy. And guess what? They're not just for Halloween - they're great for Christmas, Valentine's Day, Easter, or even your next movie marathon night!
With eighteen 2.5-ounce packages in a box, they're perfect for party sharing or trick-or-treat handouts. Bonus points for being individually wrapped, low-fat, and kosher-certified. But the fun doesn't stop there! Why not use them as straws for your milk, hot chocolate, or milkshake? Or pop them into gift bags or give them as party prizes. Their resealable packaging keeps them fresh and ready for when you fancy a snack. So, for a fun, flavorful, and festive candy twist, grab a pack of Twizzlers Twists Strawberry Flavored Licorice. They're sure to be the star of your Halloween bash!
Why Peter Piper Picked It
Craving a healthier Halloween treat? Look no further than the SmartSweets Core 4 Variety Pack! Peter Piper picked this pack as it's bursting with low-sugar, high-fiber gummies, offering all the tasty fun without the guilt. You'll get eight total packs consisting of two packs each of Sourmelon Bites, Sweet Fish, Sour Blast Buddies, and Peach Rings, all naturally sweetened with monk fruit and allulose.
No need to hold back or think twice because each bag is just 100 calories, has only 3 grams of sugar, and boasts a whopping 13 grams of filling soluble prebiotic fiber! Plus, they're gluten-free, non-GMO, free from common allergens, and certified vegan. So, if you want a guilt-free Halloween, these real-ingredient gummies are your sweet solution!
Candy Queries: FAQs About Halloween Treats
Ready for a Halloween candy crash course? We've got you covered! Halloween is all about traditions, costumes, decorations, and of course, the sweet star - candy! With so many choices, it's easy to get lost in a sugar rush. Whether you're into sour kicks or chocolate bliss, we've got the answers to your candy conundrums.
This FAQ section is your candy compass, guiding you from top-notch lollipops for your Halloween bash to gluten-free goodies for special diets. Our mission? To help you make the sweetest choices this spooky season. So, let's unwrap the sugary secrets of Halloween candies!
What makes sour candy sour?
Sour candy gets its signature taste from acidic ingredients like citric, tartaric, or malic acid. These acids react with your taste buds, causing that familiar tangy sensation. In some candies, the sour flavor is coated on the outside, while in others it's mixed into the candy itself.
How is sour gummy candy made?
The creation of sour gummy candies involves combining gelatin with sweeteners, flavors, and colors. Then, sour agents such as citric acid are added to give them their distinctive tang. Once all the ingredients are combined, they're poured into molds and cooled to create fun shapes.
How different are sour Skittles from regular ones?
Sour Skittles differ from regular Skittles primarily due to their sour sugar coating. This gives them an initial tart taste that hits your tongue as soon as you start eating. Beneath this sour exterior, however, they're just as fruity and delicious as regular Skittles.
What are the most popular Halloween candies?
Some of the most popular Halloween candies include Snickers, Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, M&M's, and Skittles. These treats have become a staple during the Halloween season due to their widespread appeal. However, it's always good to offer a variety of candies to cater to different tastes.
Why is candy corn associated with Halloween?
Candy corn has been a Halloween staple for over a century. Its colors of orange, yellow, and white are reminiscent of the autumn harvest, specifically corn. This association, along with its unique, sweet flavor, has made it a traditional Halloween treat.
Where can I find the best deals on Halloween candy?
Many retailers offer special deals on Halloween candy as the holiday approaches. Local supermarkets, online stores like Amazon, and bulk stores like Costco are great places to start looking. Keep an eye out for holiday advertising and discounts to get the most bang for your buck.
What types of lollipops are popular for Halloween?
Traditional round lollipops are always a hit during Halloween. However, Halloween-themed lollipops, such as those shaped like pumpkins or ghosts, are especially popular. These themed treats add a fun and festive touch to Halloween celebrations.
Where can I buy Halloween lollipops?
Halloween-themed lollipops can be found in most stores as Halloween approaches. Online retailers like Amazon also carry a wide variety of spooky shapes and flavors. Whether you're looking for ghost-shaped lollipops or pumpkin-flavored ones, there's likely an option for you.
Are there any gluten-free Halloween candy options?
Yes, there are many gluten-free options for Halloween candy. Lollipops and certain chocolate brands often offer gluten-free versions of their products. For example, the SmartSweets Core 4 Variety Pack is a gluten-free candy option that's perfect for those with dietary restrictions.
How can I find the best Halloween candy deals?
To find the best deals on Halloween candy, consider buying in bulk from online retailers. It's also helpful to compare prices across different stores. Additionally, keep an eye out for seasonal sales and discounts, which are common in the lead-up to Halloween.
What are some sour candies that can be included in Halloween party supplies?
Sour candies can add a tangy twist to your Halloween party supplies. Popular choices include Sour Patch Kids, Sour Skittles, and Sour Punch Straws. These candies offer a fun contrast to the traditional sugary treats often found at Halloween parties.
What are some extreme sour candies for those who love a tart treat?
For those who love a truly tart treat, consider picking up some Sour Punch Strawberry Straws or Trolli Sour Brite Crawlers. These candies are known for their extremely sour flavor, providing a fun challenge for your taste buds. They're sure to be a hit with fans of sour candies.
Sweet Endings: Your Ultimate Guide to Halloween Candies
Halloween is synonymous with candy, and after reading through our Frequently Asked Questions section, we hope you're feeling more informed and ready to make the best candy choices this spooky season. Whether you're a fan of sweet or sour, chocolate or fruity flavors, there's a Halloween candy out there that's sure to satisfy your taste buds.
When it comes time to buy Halloween candy and you are checking out your favorite online shop or store, remember, the best candy is the one that brings you joy, so don't be afraid to try something new! Take a moment to click the buttons beneath each reviewed product to check on pricing, availability, and shipping options. Happy Halloween!
